By Mr. Brown | December 20, 2024
Two Teeth Under a Plant
Sometime in the fall of 2024, an Orange County homeowner noticed two large teeth half-hidden beneath the fronds of a plant on their property near Scotchtown, a hamlet about 70 miles northwest of New York City. They picked the teeth up. Dr. Robert Feranec, director of Research and Collections and curator of Ice Age Animals at the New York State Museum, later told the Associated Press what happened in that moment: "He picked them up and realized they were teeth." That realization led the homeowner to dig a few inches into the topsoil, where two more teeth were waiting. The jaw itself was already protruding from the ground.
The family brought the teeth to SUNY Orange's Middletown campus. There, geology instructor Anthony Soricelli connected them with Dr. Cory Harris, chair of the college's Behavioral Sciences Department and a professor of anthropology and sociology. Soricelli and Harris both identified the items as mastodon teeth immediately.
Harris put the family in touch with the New York State Museum. Museum staff came to the site in Scotchtown, and Harris joined the excavation. The dig turned up a full, well-preserved mastodon jaw belonging to an adult, along with a piece of a toe bone and a rib fragment. The homeowner, who wishes to remain anonymous, described the moment of discovery in the New York State Education Department's December 17, 2024 announcement: "When I found the teeth and examined them in my hands, I knew they were something special and decided to call in the experts." They added: "I'm thrilled that our property has yielded such an important find for the scientific community."
Harris, reflecting on how the institutions coordinated, was direct about what the process demonstrated: "This process played out exactly as it should have, and became a true partnership between the state and the College."
What Was Found, and Why It Matters
According to the New York State Education Department, the Scotchtown jaw is the first complete mastodon jaw recovered in New York State in more than 11 years. That distinction matters more than it might appear on its surface.
A complete lower jaw gives researchers a great deal to work with. Tooth wear patterns carry information about diet. Bone density reflects health over a lifetime. The position and condition of the teeth can help establish the animal's age at death. A fragment can suggest; a complete specimen can answer.
The museum announced plans at the time for carbon dating and comprehensive analysis to determine the animal's age, diet, and habitat during its lifetime. Following preservation and analysis, the specimen was to be featured in public programming in 2025. The museum has not announced results from the dating or the analysis.
Harris noted that the jaw was not the only item of interest recovered: "While the jaw is the star of the show, the additional toe and rib fragments offer valuable context and the potential for additional research." He added that the team was hoping to explore the immediate area for additional material: "We are also hoping to further explore the immediate area to see if there are any additional bones that were preserved."
Feranec situated the discovery in a longer argument about why these finds matter at all. "Fossils are resources that provide remarkable snapshots of the past, allowing us to not only reconstruct ancient ecosystems but also provide us with better context and understanding of the current world around us," he said in the state release. "Each discovery like this one brings us one step closer to piecing together the full story of New York."
What a Mastodon Was
The American mastodon (Mammut americanum) was not a mammoth. The two animals are often treated as interchangeable in casual usage, but they were distinct creatures that diverged from a common ancestor millions of years ago and adapted very differently.
The most telling difference is in the teeth. Mastodon molars carry cone-shaped cusps suited to crushing branches, leaves, and woody vegetation. The mastodon was a browser, built for forested environments. Mammoth molars are broad and ridged, designed for grinding grasses. One animal worked the edges of the forest; the other was a creature of open country.
In size, mastodons were substantial. Adults stood roughly 8 to 10 feet at the shoulder. They went extinct somewhere between 10,000 and 11,000 years ago, and the causes remain debated. Climate change, the disruption of habitat as the Ice Age ended, and early human hunting have all been proposed. The question has not been settled.
Orange County's Unlikely Distinction
New York State has produced more than 150 mastodon fossils to date. About a third of them have come out of Orange County. The New York State Museum has called the county the state's premier hotspot for mastodon finds, and SUNY Orange has physical evidence of that claim standing in its lobby.
Since the 1980s, the college's Middletown campus has been home to Sugar, the Sugar Loaf mastodon. Sugar was found in 1972 near the Warwick-Chester border and was donated to the people of Orange County by the New York State Archaeological Association. Sugar greets students at the main entrance of the Bio-Tech building.
Sugar was a 20-foot-long male who stood almost nine feet tall at the pelvis and carried an unusual tusk in his lower jaw. He has been radiocarbon dated at 7910 B.C., plus or minus 225 years, making him one of the better-documented specimens in the state's collection.
The college's familiarity with what a mastodon tooth looks like was not incidental to how the Scotchtown discovery unfolded. When an Orange County family walked into SUNY Orange carrying two large teeth, the institution that already had Sugar in its building knew exactly what it was looking at. The connection between the family and the State Museum followed quickly, and the formal excavation followed from there.
Three Centuries of New York Finds
The Scotchtown jaw did not appear out of nowhere. New York has one of the longest documented records of mastodon discovery in North America.
The first known find came in 1705, according to the New York State Museum's account: a tooth fragment that turned up along the Hudson River, at Claverack, among the earliest fossil finds recorded in North America. Whatever the colonists made of it at the time, it entered the scientific record and opened what would become a long list.
The most prominent entry on that list is the Cohoes Mastodon, recovered in 1866 in the city of Cohoes and now on display at the New York State Museum in Albany. The Cohoes specimen has anchored New York's fossil history for more than 150 years.
The cumulative picture from 1705 to the present is clear: New York, and the Hudson Valley corridor in particular, preserved Ice Age megafauna unusually well. The region's geology, its former ponds and wetland basins, created conditions favorable to fossilization. That is why Orange County keeps producing mastodons, and why an excavator digging a pond in Dutchess County in 1999 turned up what it did.
Dutchess County's Own: Hyde Park
In 1999, Larry and Sheryl Lozier of Hyde Park, in Dutchess County, hired an excavator to deepen a pond beside their home. Large bones began coming up. Larry Lozier's first thought, according to reporting by the Lakeville Journal, was that the bones might have come from a cow or a horse. A neighbor corrected him on the spot: "Larry, that's no Clydesdale."
The first bone spent time in the back of Lozier's pickup before he called the Anthropology Program at Dutchess Community College. The experts there confirmed what the neighbor had suspected.
The Paleontological Research Institution, known as PRI, took over the excavation and worked the site through the following year. The final bone came out on September 17, 2000. When the work was finished, about 95 percent of the skeleton had been recovered in good condition, placing the Hyde Park mastodon among the most complete mastodon skeletons ever found in the Northeast.
The animal was an older adult male, estimated at 10,000 to 15,000 pounds in life. A preliminary carbon date taken from a tusk fragment put the animal at 11,480 years old, plus or minus 60 years. The Discovery Channel filmed the excavation for a documentary called "Mastodon in Your Backyard."
The Hyde Park Mastodon has been on display since September 2003 at PRI's Museum of the Earth in Ithaca, which opened that same year. Tens of thousands of people visit the museum annually to see it.
When the Museum Nearly Closed
For most of its existence, PRI's Museum of the Earth was sustained in large part by a single anonymous benefactor, who contributed roughly $20 million over two decades and funded the construction of the museum building in 2003. Around 2022 or 2023, that donor defaulted on an additional $30 million pledge and stopped paying the museum's mortgage.
The institution did not absorb the loss quietly. PRI laid off half its staff, undertook a strategic downsizing, and arrived at a hard deadline: retire the remaining mortgage debt, by then approximately $3 million and accruing interest at 13 percent per year, by December 31, 2025, or face foreclosure. Had the museum closed, the Hyde Park Mastodon and the rest of the collection, which runs to between 7 and 10 million specimens, would have been dispersed to other institutions, many of them outside New York.
The rescue came through in the final months of 2025. Two donations of $1 million each anchored the campaign, one of them from a Cornell alumna. Broad community giving carried the effort to its target. The Cornell Daily Sun reported in January 2026 that PRI had raised enough to pay the mortgage in full and would remain open and fully operational at least through mid-2026.
PRI director Warren Allmon told the Sun that the long-term financial model was still being worked out. The museum is operating smaller than it was before the crisis. But the Hyde Park Mastodon is still in Ithaca, the collection is intact, and the institution that saved both from dispersal is, as of that January 2026 reporting, still working out its long-term footing.
If You Find Something, Call
The New York State Museum asks members of the public to report fossil finds. The instruction is straightforward. Most of what has been recovered from private land in New York came to researchers' attention because a property owner picked up something unusual and decided to make a phone call.
The Scotchtown jaw is exactly that story. A tooth that looked, briefly, like a baseball turned out to be the beginning of the most significant mastodon jaw recovery in New York in more than a decade. The family called SUNY Orange. SUNY Orange called the State Museum. The State Museum came to the backyard. A complete jaw, a toe bone, and a rib fragment are now in the hands of researchers who can tell us something about an animal that moved through this landscape when the Ice Age was ending.
That outcome required one thing before anything else could happen: a homeowner who recognized that the teeth in their hands were worth a phone call. The rest followed from there.
Sources
- SUNY Orange, "Original 2024 Discovery"
- Associated Press via phys.org, "New York man finds mastodon jaw while gardening in his backyard" (Dec 18, 2024)
- Smithsonian Magazine, "A Homeowner Found Huge, Fossil Teeth While Mowing the Lawn..." (Dec 19, 2024)
- Live Science, "New York homeowner discovers mastodon jaw fossils in their backyard"
- Paleontological Research Institution, "The Hyde Park mastodon, 13,000 + 20 years later"
- Lakeville Journal, "Delving into the past of Dutchess County and the Hyde Park mastodon"
- Hudson Valley Magazine, "Museum That Houses Hyde Park Mastodon at Risk of Closure" (Nov 5, 2025)
- Cornell Daily Sun, "'Something Close to a Miracle': How Donations, Community Efforts Saved the Museum of the Earth" (Jan 2026)

