Columbia Memorial Update: Barrett Asks the State to Reject the Bed Cut as Hudson’s Hospital Fight Widens

An ambulance on a rural Hudson Valley road at dusk, driving toward the warm lights of a small hospital on a hill

The road to Hudson.

By June Mercer | November 21, 2026

New York Assemblymember Didi Barrett is calling on the state to reject Albany Med Health System's plan to convert Columbia Memorial Health into a critical access hospital. Barrett's position, reported by the Times Union on November 20, 2026, puts a state lawmaker formally on record against a proposal that community members have fought since summer. It adds legislative weight to a campaign that has drawn hundreds of residents and medical professionals over the past several months.

Albany Med's Proposal

Albany Med Health System filed an application with the state Department of Health to redesignate Columbia Memorial Health, located in Hudson, under a federal critical access classification. That designation carries strict conditions: a cap of 25 inpatient beds, an average patient stay of no more than four days, and a location that meets minimum-distance requirements from other hospitals.

In exchange, critical access hospitals receive higher Medicare reimbursement rates. Albany Med says the hospital is not fully using its current 70 beds, and a health system spokesperson said the facility would retain all current services while freeing up investment in new and enhanced ones. The emergency room would remain open. Albany Med also said it plans to expand a clinic in Greene County as part of its broader regional strategy.

The application was still pending state review as of October 26, 2026, according to WAMC.

Opposition Grows

Columbia Memorial serves Hudson and much of the surrounding Columbia County region. Critics argue that cutting inpatient capacity to 25 beds would leave residents with fewer options and, for many, no realistic alternative.

The Save CMH Coalition formed in direct response to the proposal. Rallies in mid-July 2026 and again on September 14, 2026, drew public crowds and kept pressure on Albany Med and state regulators alike.

The coalition describes the conversion as a cut from roughly 100 inpatient beds to 25. Albany Med's public statements reference 70 current beds; the two figures have not been reconciled in publicly available filings reviewed for this article.

Frontline staff raised specific concerns about capacity. Sara Dragula, an emergency room nurse at Columbia Memorial, told WAMC the hospital typically holds between 30 and 50 admitted patients at any given time. Capping inpatient beds at 25, she said, would leave the ER more crowded, with fewer places to put patients who need admission.

For patients, the distance is a hard stop. Critics say people who can no longer get certain services locally would face a roughly one-hour drive north to Albany. For elderly and low-income residents in the area, that drive is not always possible.

Sarah Rebekah Garber, a nurse practitioner who works in the community, made that plain in an interview with WAMC. "I utilize this hospital daily," Garber said. "All my patients go here. Many of them are elderly, cannot make the drive up to Albany, cannot make the drive down to Kingston, and they're just going to forgo care."

A Demand to Show the Work

On September 2, 2026, the Save CMH Coalition brought its case to the Greene County Public Safety committee. Coalition members asked lawmakers to write to the state Department of Health, demanding that Albany Med "show its work" before the state approved any reduction to 25 beds.

Legislators did not vote at that meeting but agreed to draft their own resolution in support of transparency during the state review process.

That request captures the coalition's core position. Albany Med says the redesignation protects and grows services. The coalition and its allies want that claim supported by data, made public, and scrutinized before the state makes any decision.

The Financial Pressure Behind the Plan

Columbia Memorial's situation is not isolated. Hospital systems across New York have faced mounting pressure since Congress passed H.R.1, known as Trump's "One Big Beautiful Bill Act," last year. The legislation reduced federal funding flowing to states, including New York. The Iroquois Healthcare Association flagged the downstream pressure on rural providers in reporting by WAMC.

The critical access designation would bring Columbia Memorial higher Medicare reimbursement rates, and Albany Med cites that financial benefit as part of its rationale. Critics do not dispute that rural hospitals face real financial strain. Their argument is that cutting beds is the wrong response to it, and that the community deserves a full accounting before the state weighs in.

The Decision Ahead

The state Department of Health has not announced a decision timeline. Barrett's call for rejection gives regulators a clear legislative signal, but the final authority rests with the state agency.

For the Save CMH Coalition, the demand has not changed: transparency before any approval. For patients in Columbia County, the outcome will shape what local care looks like for years ahead.

Sources

June Mercer

June Mercer covers Dutchess County and the wider Hudson Valley for Reporting from the Uncanny Valley and edits its free newsletter. She writes about town boards, roads, schools, land, and the small stories that turn out not to be small. She lives in Stanfordville.

Previous
Previous

Carmel School Evacuated After Boiler Room Carbon Monoxide Readings Top 100 Parts Per Million

Next
Next

Update: The Hacking Agents Found a Zero-Day Nobody Knew Existed, and There Is Still No Patched Release to Install