Document it first.
By Mara Quinn | November 18, 2026
Carolyn Scott spent eight months without running water at Riverview Condos in Poughkeepsie. She heated her home with the oven. When the homeowners association held a meeting, Poughkeepsie Common Councilmember Ernest Henry attended and said he was dismayed at what he heard from residents, many of them senior citizens, pointing to a roof with holes and no heat in the apartments, according to WAMC. Fellow resident Robert Evans is suing the HOA board of managers and J and J Management Services, in a lawsuit filed in Dutchess County Supreme Court in June, alleging that a New Year's Day fire started because of unsafe conditions, including a hot water heater that was not properly maintained and a failure to provide smoke detectors and appropriate sprinkler systems. The defendants denied all allegations in court documents and did not respond to WAMC requests for comment. Evans told WAMC he still pays $518 a month in common fees and cannot live in the unit.
Scott, Evans, and their neighbors are dealing with a situation many Dutchess County residents face without knowing what recourse they have. New York law gives you specific tools if your heat is out, your water is gone, or your building is unsafe. Here is how to use them.
One rule before anything else: If there is an immediate danger, call 9-1-1. The steps below cover housing violations that require documentation and official reporting, not active emergencies.
This article provides general information only. It is not legal advice.
Step 1: Document the Conditions Before You Do Anything Else
Take dated photos and videos of every problem you can see: the broken radiator, the hole in the roof, the wet ceiling, the missing smoke detector. Write down exact dates, times, and what you observed. Save every text, email, or voicemail from your landlord or property manager.
Your records are the foundation for every step that follows. If your building loses heat or water, note the start date and log how long the outage lasts. If other residents share your concerns, ask them to document their own conditions separately: parallel records from multiple units carry more weight than a single complaint.
Step 2: Put Your Complaint in Writing to the Landlord or HOA
Once you have a record, notify the responsible party in writing. Email is acceptable. Certified mail is better, because it creates a delivery record. State the problem plainly and set a reasonable deadline for repair.
This step matters legally. According to the Attorney General's guidance, landlords of multiple dwellings must keep apartments and public areas in good repair, and must maintain electrical, plumbing, sanitary, heating and ventilating systems in good and safe working order. Repairs must be made within a reasonable time, which varies with severity. Keep copies of everything you send.
Step 3: Know the Standards the Law Actually Sets
New York law defines what acceptable housing looks like. The heating season runs October 1 through May 31. Between 6 a.m. and 10 p.m., your apartment must reach at least 68 degrees Fahrenheit when the outside temperature falls below 55 degrees. Between 10 p.m. and 6 a.m., the inside temperature must hold at or above 62 degrees regardless of the weather. Hot water must be available every day of the year at a minimum of 120 degrees Fahrenheit.
New York's warranty of habitability requires that every residential rental remain safe, sanitary, and livable. The protection is implied in every lease, you cannot give it up, and any lease clause that tries to strip it away is void. It covers individual units and public areas. Examples of a violation include not providing heat or hot water on a regular basis and not ridding an apartment of an insect infestation.
These are enforceable standards, not aspirations. Knowing them lets you describe a violation precisely when you file.
Step 4: File a Complaint with the City
For properties within the City of Poughkeepsie, start with the city's Department of Building. The city states that the department is responsible for ordinance enforcement including construction codes and the property maintenance code. The department is at 62 Civic Center Plaza and reachable at 845-451-4007. City Hall is at 845-451-4200. The city lists its Fire Department at 845-451-4079, the number to use for fire safety concerns of the kind alleged in the Evans lawsuit, such as missing smoke detectors.
The city launched PK Connect on October 2, 2026, according to the Poughkeepsie Journal: a free app for iPhone and Android that lets residents report non-emergency problems, including code enforcement concerns, and track progress and receive updates on reported issues.
When you file, attach your photos and reference the written notice you sent in Step 2, and follow up in writing if the problem is not addressed.
Step 5: Escalate If Local Action Stalls
Local enforcement does not always move fast. If it stalls, escalate. Attorney General Letitia James urges tenants who believe their rights have been violated to file a complaint with her office online or by calling 1-800-771-7755, after documenting the issue, notifying the landlord in writing, and contacting the local agency.
If you are a rent-regulated tenant, the Division of Housing and Community Renewal can order a rent reduction for a breach of the warranty. You must first give written notice to your landlord, and the complaint can only be filed at least 10 days and no more than 60 days after that notice. A tenant can also sue for a rent reduction, according to the Attorney General's guidance.
Under Real Property Law Section 227, a tenant may vacate and cancel a lease if the apartment is uninhabitable because of fire or damage the tenant did not cause. Consult a lawyer before taking that step. Vacating without legal cover can create its own problems.
Step 6: Get Free Legal Help
You do not need money to get a lawyer. Legal Services of the Hudson Valley offers free comprehensive civil legal assistance, including help with housing matters such as evictions, foreclosures, and landlord-tenant disputes. Eligibility typically depends on income level, legal issue, and residency, and its services are aimed at low-income individuals and families, seniors, veterans, and people with disabilities in the Hudson Valley. Call 1-877-574-8529.
Many Riverview residents are seniors, one of the groups the organization says its work is aimed at. Call before a situation becomes a crisis, and have the papers and the log from Step 1 ready: the organization asks callers to have the relevant documents available.
If You Own Your Condo Unit, the Path Differs
The warranty of habitability does not protect condo owners making claims against their own HOA. What it does protect is any tenant or subtenant renting inside a condo, and owners of cooperative apartments can raise it.
Condo owners facing maintenance failures should put every complaint in writing to the board and the management company, file code and fire safety complaints with the city, and consult an attorney. The DHCR rent-reduction route is a tenant route, not an owner route.
Document first. Write second. File third. Do not wait.
Sources
- WAMC: Poughkeepsie condo residents complain of substandard conditions
- New York Attorney General: Legal services and code enforcement
- New York Attorney General: Attorney General James Reminds Tenants of Their Rights Amid Winter Storm
- City of Poughkeepsie: Departments
- Poughkeepsie Journal: City of Poughkeepsie launches new free app to report local problems
- Legal Services of the Hudson Valley: FAQs

