The median, after the landing.
By June Mercer | November 16, 2026
Federal investigators have determined what caused a small plane to fall into the median of Interstate 684 in Westchester County: water had contaminated both fuel tanks, the preflight inspection failed to catch it, and the engine stopped twice during the attempt to reach Westchester County Airport.
The National Transportation Safety Board released findings reported by Mid Hudson Valley Patch on November 16, 2026. These findings trace the crash to a failure chain that started before the flight ever left the ground.
What the NTSB Found
The airplane owner, who held a private pilot certificate and had recently purchased the aircraft, was at the controls when the trouble started. A commercial-rated safety pilot occupied the right seat. According to the report, both completed a preflight inspection and engine run-up before departure and found nothing wrong.
About 30 minutes after takeoff, the owner heard an abnormal noise and noticed a loss of engine power. The safety pilot took control. One of the pilots told air traffic control they needed to divert to the nearest airport, Westchester County Airport.
Shortly after that call, one of the pilots switched fuel tanks and engine power returned. The crew told controllers they would continue to the airport. About two minutes later, the engine lost power again.
This time there was no recovery. The controller cleared the airplane to land, but the crew could not reach the runway. The safety pilot aimed for a forced landing on a road. The owner raised a concern about landing against oncoming traffic. The safety pilot turned steeply left toward another road the owner could not see. The plane struck the median of I-684 near Exit 2 in the Town of Harrison. A witness told investigators the aircraft "fell very fast out of the sky and crashed in the center median."
Investigators found water in both fuel tanks, both carburetor bowls, the fuel supply hose to the right carburetor, and in liquid drained from the engine-driven fuel pump. The engine itself showed no mechanical problems. An extended test run after the crash found no anomalies, confirming that contaminated fuel, not a mechanical defect, stopped the engine.
The report identified where the water came from. Both fuel caps leaked. Pressure testing confirmed it. The left fuel cap carried damage in two areas and was missing its o-ring. The right cap appeared undamaged, but its stud did not extend below the length of the self-locking nut, leaving an incomplete seal. Heavy rain in the days before the crash likely pushed water through both caps while the plane sat outside.
A Warning the Records Captured
The NTSB noted a prior episode that makes the finding more troubling. About five months before the crash, water contamination in the fuel system stopped the engine immediately after start, following an annual inspection. The root cause was never investigated.
Less than two weeks before the crash, the airplane went through a second annual inspection. The owner purchased it two days after that inspection closed. The water problem that halted the engine months earlier had not been traced to any specific source.
Why Water Stops an Aviation Engine
Aviation fuel systems are built for one thing: fuel. Water does not burn. When water reaches the carburetor in sufficient volume, it displaces the fuel-air mixture the engine needs to fire. The result is a power loss that can be sudden and can recur if contamination is spread across both tanks.
Standard preflight procedure for piston aircraft includes draining small samples from the sump ports at the bottom of each tank and checking them for water. Because water is denser than aviation fuel, it sinks to the low points of the system. Those sump checks are the primary defense against exactly this kind of contamination. The NTSB found the checks before this flight did not detect the water already present in the system.
Why This Finding Matters Along I-684
For Hudson Valley commuters, I-684 is part of the daily routine. The stretch near Exit 2, in the Town of Harrison, sits at the southern end of a corridor that links Westchester to Putnam County and beyond. When a small plane struck the median there, the cause remained unknown for months.
An official finding replaces speculation with a cause chain that investigators and aircraft owners can act on. It identifies where the inspection failed, what the fuel caps should have done, and what the rain exploited. It points to places in the safety process where the outcome could have been different.
The NTSB findings were reported by Patch's Mid Hudson Valley edition on November 16, 2026.

