The uprights, after the rain.
By June Mercer | November 15, 2026
Marist came into Saturday's game at Tenney Stadium with a slim shot at the Pioneer Football League title. It left with nothing on the scoreboard and nothing left in the standings fight. Butler won 28-0 before 2,167 fans in Poughkeepsie, handing the Red Foxes their third loss in four games and ending their PFL title hopes for good.
Marist's Offense Could Not Convert When It Counted
The numbers were stark. Marist managed 193 total yards, converted just 2 of 15 third downs, and punted seven times. Ethan Yuska averaged 37.7 yards on those punts, kicking from deep in Marist territory more often than not. The Red Foxes went 1-for-5 on fourth down and turned the ball over twice.
Quarterback Sonny Mannino completed 18 of 32 passes for 138 yards. He was intercepted twice and sacked six times for a loss of 34 yards. Those six sacks made it hard to find any rhythm. Mannino drove Marist to the Butler 13 in the second quarter, but Andrew Lieske's interception ended the threat. Marist gained only 52 rushing yards all afternoon. Isaiah Simmons led the ground game with 36 yards on 10 carries.
In the passing game, Reed Shumpert led receivers with 48 yards on three catches. Lincoln Cardillo added five catches for 32 yards, and Zach Garmont caught three passes for 25 yards. The targets were spread around, but the production was not enough.
Head coach Mike Willis put it plainly after the game. "There was plenty of great effort," Willis said, according to the Times Herald-Record. "Simply, we did not execute well enough... it's a game of execution. Credit to Butler."
A Scoring Streak Stopped Cold
Marist had scored in 13 consecutive games before Saturday. The last shutout came on November 1, 2025, when Saint Thomas (Minn.) beat the Red Foxes 45-0. Butler made that history repeat. The Bulldogs had already blanked Franklin earlier this season and held eight opponents under 87 rushing yards this year. Saturday was their second shutout of 2026.
Butler Built the Lead One Drive at a Time
The Bulldogs did not need a big play to open the scoring. Michael Dellumo punched in a 6-yard touchdown run in the second quarter, cashing in after Butler's defense stopped Mannino's drive to the 13 and came away with the interception.
Dellumo scored again in the third quarter on a 3-yard run. That drive benefited from one of the more unusual sequences of the afternoon. On third down, Butler used a quick kick that pinned Marist back to its own 2-yard line. Marist went three-and-out from there, and Madden Beriault returned the punt to the Marist 13. The short field led directly to Dellumo's second score. Per Butler University Athletics, it was the second straight week he crossed the goal line twice.
The fourth quarter brought two scores inside two minutes. Gabe Passini capped an 11-play, 56-yard drive with a 1-yard run to push the lead to 21-0. Ninety-two seconds later, Desmin Jackson scored on a 6-yard run. Tristan Johnson had intercepted Mannino and returned it 42 yards to set up that final touchdown, turning a Marist possession into a quick Butler score.
The Efficiency Behind the Scoreboard
Passini completed 10 of 16 passes for 101 yards and added 69 yards on 14 carries. Dellumo rushed 12 times for 46 yards. Jackson carried eight times for 26 yards.
On defense, Jayden Norris recorded 2.5 sacks. Jackson Stratton finished with eight tackles. Kade Werner led the Marist defense with nine stops.
Standings, Series History, and the Final Week
The loss dropped Marist to 5-6 overall and 4-3 in PFL play. Butler improved to 9-2 and 6-1 in the conference, tied for first place with Dayton.
Butler has beaten Marist four times in a row since 2021. The Bulldogs now lead the all-time series 5-4.
Before the game, Marist honored 21 senior athletes and two managers on Senior Day at Tenney Stadium. That ceremony preceded one of the program's harder afternoons of the season.
Marist closes out at Davidson on November 21, with kickoff at 1 p.m. Butler hosts Morehead State the same day at 1 p.m., tied for first place in the PFL.

