By Mr. Brown | December 7, 2024
What a Tornado Actually Is
A tornado is a narrow, violently rotating column of air that extends from a thunderstorm to the ground. That much is settled. What happens inside the storm system to produce one is still a matter of active research.
The National Severe Storms Laboratory puts it plainly: "we don't fully understand" how tornadoes form. The NSSL carries that admission as a central position, not a footnote, and the science bears it out. The most destructive and deadly tornadoes come from supercells, rotating thunderstorms that develop a well-defined radar circulation called a mesocyclone. A mesocyclone is typically two to six miles across, considerably larger than any tornado that develops within it.
Current understanding holds that formation is driven mainly by things happening at the storm scale, in and around the mesocyclone. Findings from the VORTEX2 research program tie tornado development to temperature differences across the edge of downdraft air wrapping around the mesocyclone. Computer modeling, however, shows that tornadoes can form without those patterns. Very little temperature variation was observed near some of the most destructive tornadoes in history, including those of May 3, 1999. The process that converts a rotating supercell into a tornado on the ground remains an open question.
About 1,200 tornadoes strike the United States each year, a figure derived from official records dating to 1950. Tornadoes have been documented in all fifty states. The seasonal pattern shifts by region: the Southeast faces elevated risk in cooler months, the southern and central Plains in May and June, the northern Plains and Midwest in early summer. Most tornadoes occur between four and nine in the afternoon.
Rating Strength: The Enhanced Fujita Scale
Tornado intensity is assigned after the event, from the damage left behind. Meteorologists and engineers examine what was destroyed and estimate the wind speeds required to produce it. The Enhanced Fujita Scale, adopted by the National Weather Service in 2007, provides the framework: 28 damage indicators, including specific building types, structures, and trees, each with eight degrees of damage from threshold to near-complete destruction.
The EF scale runs from EF0 through EF5. An EF0 carries winds of 65 to 85 mph. EF1 runs from 86 to 110 mph. EF2 covers 111 to 135 mph. EF3 runs 136 to 165 mph. EF4 covers 166 to 200 mph. An EF5 exceeds 200 mph.
Because the rating is derived from damage analysis rather than direct wind measurement, the scale reflects the tornado's effect on the built environment as directly as it reflects the wind speed itself.
The Stakes Made Local: Rome, New York, July 16, 2024
Tornadoes are often thought of as a central plains event. The afternoon of July 16, 2024, in upstate New York offers a precise correction.
The remnants of Hurricane Beryl tracked north and east that day, adding rotational energy to the atmosphere across the region. Discrete supercells developed, and the National Weather Service office in Binghamton confirmed multiple tornadoes across New York State. One touched down at 3:25 PM between the Erie Canal and Muck Road in Oneida County, passed directly through the city of Rome, and lifted just past Griffiss International Airport. The NWS Binghamton damage survey rated it a high-end EF2, with estimated maximum winds of 135 mph. The tornado traveled more than five miles. Along the way, it tore the steeples off two churches.
Governor Kathy Hochul called it the worst natural disaster to hit the city of Rome in its 228-year history, according to WAMC.
The Rome tornado did not occur in isolation. July 2024 set a New York State record: at least 18 confirmed tornadoes in the state that month, according to WAMC citing National Weather Service figures. New York sees fewer than a dozen tornadoes in a typical year. The July total was nearly double that baseline, compressed into a single month.
The Rome storm lasted minutes and covered five miles. The margin between a warning that reaches people in time and one that does not is measured in the same increments. Detection technology matters as much as the storm science itself.
How Forecasters See What Is Coming
Modern tornado detection runs through radar, and the usefulness of radar for tornado forecasting owes a significant debt to the National Severe Storms Laboratory.
NSSL built the first real-time displays of Doppler radar velocity data. An NSSL scientist discovered the Tornadic Vortex Signature, or TVS, in that velocity data during the 1970s. The TVS is a pattern of intense concentrated rotation that can appear on radar several kilometers above the ground before a tornado touches down. It does not guarantee that a tornado will form, but it sharply raises the probability and gives forecasters lead time to issue warnings. This work helped drive deployment of the WSR-88D NEXRAD network, and the Department of Commerce awarded NSSL a Gold Medal for its contribution to that network.
A second signature, the hook echo, appears in radar reflectivity data as a curved appendage on the right-rear side of a storm. It results from the rear flank downdraft wrapping precipitation around the updraft and is associated with mesocyclone rotation.
Dual-polarization radar, now standard on National Weather Service radars, adds a further layer. Traditional radar transmits and receives a single horizontal signal. Dual-pol transmits both horizontal and vertical pulses simultaneously. The difference in return signals can identify irregular, randomly tumbling objects, which is to say debris: leaves, insulation, structural material lofted by a tornado. A debris signature on dual-pol gives forecasters high confidence that a damaging tornado is on the ground. This matters most at night, when visual confirmation from spotters is difficult or impossible.
Phased array radar extends the capability further. NSSL adapted the technology from Navy ship surveillance systems. A phased array antenna can scan an entire storm in less than one minute, compared to the several minutes required by a conventional rotating-dish radar. That speed yields earlier detection of developing rotation. NSSL has also developed a New Tornado Detection Algorithm that uses machine learning to calculate the probability a tornado is present with each radar scan. The algorithm is evaluated at NOAA's Hazardous Weather Testbed.
The public-facing output of all this technology arrives in two forms. A Tornado WATCH, issued by the NOAA Storm Prediction Center, signals that atmospheric conditions favor tornado development. A Tornado WARNING, issued by the local National Weather Service office, means a tornado has been reported by spotters or indicated on radar. A warning is not a recommendation to prepare. It is a directive to act.
Twister, 1996: Science Fiction That Trained a Generation
Released May 10, 1996, and directed by Jan de Bont from a screenplay by Michael Crichton and Anne-Marie Martin, Twister stars Helen Hunt as Dr. Jo Harding and Bill Paxton as Bill Harding, storm chasers racing through Oklahoma. The film grossed about $496 million worldwide, making it the second-highest-grossing film of 1996 behind Independence Day.
The film's central device, Dorothy, is a drum-shaped canister designed to release hundreds of sensor balls into a tornado's funnel. Dorothy's actual predecessor was TOTO, the TOtable Tornado Observatory, built by NSSL researchers. According to the Tornado Project, TOTO was a 55-gallon drum instrument package weighing about 400 pounds, designed to be set down in the path of an approaching tornado in roughly 30 seconds from a pickup truck. It carried sensors for pressure, humidity, temperature, wind speed and direction, and electrical field. TOTO was deployed through the 1980s. It never received a direct tornado strike. The reason is the same problem the film dramatizes without solving: a tornado's exact path cannot be predicted with enough precision to place a stationary ground instrument in it. TOTO was retired with its primary mission unaccomplished. The film draws loosely from real NSSL research programs, including VORTEX.
The influence on the field turned out to be measurable. Sean Waugh, an NSSL research meteorologist who served as tornado consultant on the 2024 sequel, said at a Hollywood Climate Summit panel that undergraduate meteorology enrollment across the country tripled after Twister was released and remained elevated for twenty years, according to a Hollywood Reporter account of the panel. He predicted the sequel would produce a similar effect.
A film that presented its main instrument inaccurately, and that placed storm chasers in dramatic situations well beyond routine field work, nonetheless sent a generation of students into atmospheric science for twenty years. The gap between what Twister depicted and what it inspired is not small.
Twisters, 2024: Better Science, Same Scale Problem
Twisters is a standalone film with no returning characters from the original. It was released in U.S. theaters on July 19, 2024, directed by Lee Isaac Chung from a screenplay by Mark L. Smith. The cast includes Daisy Edgar-Jones as Kate, alongside Glen Powell and Anthony Ramos. The production budget was $155 million. The film grossed about $372 million worldwide.
Kevin Kelleher, a retired NOAA laboratory director, consulted on the original 1996 film and spent more than two years as tornado consultant on Twisters. His assessment of the science, offered to Science News, was direct: "Even after 30 years from the first movie to now, we really don't know exactly how tornadoes form."
The film's central premise is tornado taming. Kate's team develops a method of releasing sodium polyacrylate into a tornado's funnel to absorb the moisture feeding the storm. Late in the film, the approach is modified with the addition of silver iodide. Kelleher identified the taming plot as the film's most fantastical element, while acknowledging to Science News that superabsorbent polyacrylate compounds can hold up to 1,000 times their weight in water, so there is a chemical basis for the concept. The obstacle is scale. His words: "It's a matter of scale. You can't hardly imagine getting enough of this chemical in the storm to make a difference." The volume of water vapor sustaining a supercell cannot be addressed by any realistic dispersal of chemical agents.
Where the film held closer to real science, working meteorologists noticed. Maria Molina of the University of Maryland told Science News that the film's depiction of mobile phased-array radar deployment was credible: the story shows three radar units positioned to triangulate a supercell, and NSSL field crews really do deploy multiple mobile radars around a storm to build a full three-dimensional picture of its dynamics. Michael Seger, chief meteorologist at KJRH in Tulsa, said the storm-chaser culture shown on screen, its jargon and gas-station routines, was accurate, according to Time. The storms themselves were built with meteorologist input, and their visual behavior reflected genuine storm science.
Director Chung addressed the question of scientific lineage at a Hollywood Reporter panel. The original film's Dorothy device was, he said, "completely science fiction," but it "inspired a generation of people to want to do scientific research on storms." The taming concept in the sequel follows the same logic: fictional in execution, grounded in real chemistry and real-world questions about whether severe storms can be influenced at all.
Kelleher offered a practical note on the culture the films celebrate. At the Hollywood Climate Summit panel, he said: storm chasing "is really dangerous to go out and do this stuff. Don't do this."
The Questions Are Still the Point
Both films are, at their core, about researchers who have not yet found the answer they are looking for. That framing is accurate. The questions on screen, why do tornadoes form when and where they do, can warning times be extended, can the storms be influenced at all, are not settled problems. They are active research questions, worked on at NSSL, evaluated in NOAA's Hazardous Weather Testbed, and occasionally advanced by field campaigns that place instrumented vehicles into severe weather.
The films turn that uncertainty into dramatic arcs and resolve it with fictional devices. What they capture, less by design than by subject matter, is a field still genuinely in the middle of its problem. The researchers who built TOTO and deployed it through a decade of chasing without ever getting a direct hit, and the retired laboratory director who spent more than two years advising on a sequel while telling reporters that tornado formation is still not fully understood, are not background figures. They are what the story is actually about.
Sources
- NSSL, Severe Weather 101: Tornado Basics
- NSSL, Severe Weather 101: Tornado Detection
- NOAA/NWS Storm Prediction Center, The Online Tornado FAQ
- National Weather Service Binghamton, Severe Storms July 2024
- WAMC, "New York experienced a record number of tornadoes in July"
- Science News, "'Twisters' asks if you can 'tame' a tornado. We have the answer"
- Slashfilm, "Is Twisters Scientifically Accurate?"
- Wikipedia, Twister (1996 film)
- Wikipedia, Twisters (film)

