Order the Whole Thanksgiving Dinner Instead: The Hudson Valley Takeout Map, With the Deadlines That Matter

A Hudson Valley farmstand with pies, squash and turkeys in late autumn light

The feast, ordered ahead.

By Mara Quinn | November 15, 2026

Skip the cooking this Thanksgiving. Fourteen Hudson Valley restaurants and caterers will have a complete feast ready for pickup, with windows centered on November 25 and a handful open Thanksgiving morning.

Hudson Valley Magazine's November 5 guide compiled the full list, covering spots across Dutchess, Ulster, and Orange counties. Here is what to order, what each spot includes, and which deadlines cannot wait.

Dutchess County

Mill House Brewing Company, Poughkeepsie (pickup November 25) puts together a $375 full feast, its "whole enchilada," with slow-roasted turkey and all the fixings. A la carte choices include cornbread, roasted garlic mashed potatoes, scratch-made cranberry sauce, sausage stuffing and herb-roasted turkey, plus pumpkin brown sugar butter cake, and drinks such as boozy eggnog or craft beers.

Rosticceria Rossi & Sons, also in Poughkeepsie (pickup November 25), goes Italian. Feast packages offer a choice of eggplant rollatini, meatballs or chicken marsala, with Italian sausage stuffing, broccoli rabe, three-cheese mashed potatoes and roasted vegetables. An antipasto platter can be added, and desserts include tiramisu and spice Hudson Valley apple crumb pie.

Terrapin, Rhinebeck (pickup November 25, 2 to 6 p.m.) covers the sides while you handle the turkey: salads, fall soups, cheddar mac and cheese, vegetarian chestnut stuffing, cornbread sausage stuffing, sweet potato gratin, mashed potatoes, glazed carrots, vegetable terrine, brioche rolls, and both pumpkin and apple pie.

The Grove Restaurant and Bar at Red Hook Golf Club (pickup November 25, 2 to 5 p.m.) covers the classics: butternut squash soup, garlic mashed potatoes, sweet potato casserole, baked mac and cheese, green bean casserole, sparkling cranberry sauce, maple roasted heirloom carrots, turkey breast, and apple or pumpkin pie.

McKinney & Doyle, Pawling runs the earliest pickup window in Dutchess, spanning November 24 and 25. Appetizers include asiago cheese sticks, asparagus stilton pastries, and jumbo lump crab cakes. Sides cover cranberry walnut sauce, garlic mashed potatoes, candy bourbon pecan sweet potatoes, and roasted chestnut stuffing. Pies, tarts, and pound cakes round out the menu.

Ulster and Orange Counties

Blackbarn Hudson Valley, Saugerties (pickup November 25 and 26) offers fresh rolls, whipped honey butter, mixed greens salad, roasted turkey breast, cranberry sauce, roasted garlic mashed potatoes, green beans, and classic brioche stuffing, with a charcuterie board, butternut bisque, and candied Brussels sprouts available as add-ons.

Blue Mountain Bistro, Kingston (pickup November 25 and 26) covers pumpkin cider bisque, turkey with all fixings, wild rice stuffing, sweet potato casserole, sausage and fennel stuffing, and roasted root vegetables. An individual dinner with a pie slice runs $48.

Main Course Catering, New Paltz (pickup November 25 and 26) handles full customization: appetizers, soups, salads, sauces, whole turkeys, vegetarian entrees, traditional sides, chocolate bread pudding, salted maple pie, and coconut quinoa pudding.

Talbott & Arding, Hudson (pickup November 25) brings a sharper edge to the spread. The menu includes cheese and charcuterie platters, shrimp cocktail, turkey with herbed bread stuffing, Brussels sprouts, potato and celery root puree or Hasselback butternut squash, and Dutch apple crumb pie served with Cabot Clothbound Cheddar.

Blu Pointe, Newburgh (pickup November 26, 11 a.m. to 3 p.m.) handles Thanksgiving morning, with the meal for two arriving hot: salad, artisan rolls, carved turkey, homestyle gravy, herbed stuffing, roasted sweet potatoes with bourbon glaze, garlic mashed potatoes, cranberry-orange compote, green bean casserole, and apple pie.

Brothers Barbecue, New Windsor (pickup November 26, 11 a.m. to 4 p.m.) takes a different approach: slow-smoked, fried, or boneless turkey, smoked prime rib, mashed potatoes, cornbread, smoked beans, cheese grits, sweet potato souffle, and apple, pecan, pumpkin, or sweet potato pie. Brothers Barbecue sells out every year. Order early.

Blooming Hill Farm, Monroe (pickup November 25, 9 a.m. to 2 p.m.) carries the earliest hard deadline on this list: orders close November 20. That is this Friday. The farm, which grows more than 200 varieties of fruits and vegetables, offers whole brined turkeys, roasted root vegetables, farm polenta, Blooming Hill stuffing, cranberry sauce, mashed potatoes, heritage bacon, and homemade pies.

Red Horse by David Burke, White Plains (pickup November 26, 9 to 11:30 a.m.) rounds out the region with a Grab n' Gobble feast for up to 10 people. The package covers a whole turkey, maple whipped sweet potatoes, sausage stuffing, gravy, cranberry orange ginger relish, roasted autumn vegetables, and pumpkin, apple, and pecan pie. Half-orders, priced at half the full rate, serve four to six people.

Order Now, Not Later

Most pickup windows fall on November 25. Restaurants offering November 26 options give Thanksgiving morning flexibility, but those windows are short, and several close by midday.

Two deadlines require action today. Blooming Hill Farm stops taking orders this Friday, November 20. Brothers Barbecue sells out without exception - early ordering is not a suggestion.

This coverage runs alongside RFTUV's Holiday Helping Hand series, which looks at community resources across the Hudson Valley this season. The restaurant guide covers a different kind of need: a full Thanksgiving dinner, made by someone else, waiting when you are ready for it.

Milton Point Provisions, Rye (pickup November 24-25) also appears in the guide: a dinner package feeding six to eight, with herb-roasted turkey, classic turkey gravy, bacon and sage stuffing, fresh cranberry sauce, one pie, classic mashed potatoes and roasted fall vegetables, with cheddar chive biscuits, crudite, and charcuterie available a la carte.

Call or check each restaurant's website directly before placing an order. Menus and availability can shift closer to the holiday.

Sources

Mara Quinn

Mara Quinn is Reporting from the Uncanny Valley's resident expert on media and the business of technology. She covers platforms, deals, incentives, and the money moving underneath new machines. She lives in Beacon.

Previous
Previous

Wallkill Police and FBI Arrest a Mount Hope Man in a Child Exploitation Investigation

Next
Next

The Agent Ordered 72 Eggs That Were Not on the List. Asked Why, It Said: No Reason. That Is on Me.