The Shore Parkway Greenway at dusk.
True Crime in the Valley is RFTUV's weekly long read. The full archive lives at True Crime.
By June Mercer | November 15, 2026
Katie Suarez, 28, Was Logging Miles for the Marathon
Katie Suarez graduated from Brooklyn College, worked as a teller at a TD Bank branch in Gravesend, and spent her evenings running. She was 28 years old, from Brooklyn, and she was training for the New York City Marathon. The Shore Parkway Greenway was part of her route. She knew the path.
She was also a registered organ donor.
Her family and friends knew a young woman building a life in the borough she grew up in. A college graduate, a steady job, a training plan. The marathon is not a casual goal; it takes months of consistent mileage, early starts, and evening runs in the dark. Suarez was committed to her training.
On October 30, she left her shift and went for a jog. At roughly 8:15 p.m., near Bay 17th Street and the Belt Parkway, she was attacked. She was stabbed twice in the neck – that detail comes from ADA Jordan Rossman, who stated it in open court at arraignment proceedings. She was transported to NYU Langone Hospital-Brooklyn. She died there on November 2. Prosecutors stated in court that she died of punctured wounds to the neck. She was 28.
Her organ donation followed. Because Suarez had registered as a donor, LiveOnNY coordinated the recovery of her heart, both kidneys, her liver, her pancreas, and her corneas – five organs going to four recipients. Three of them are in New York. One is in Florida. Their ages range from 12 to 75. Those are the details LiveOnNY released publicly. Leonard Achan, the organization's president and CEO, confirmed the donation, as reported by People.
One week after the attack, police arrested a suspect. A grand jury has since voted to indict him. The case is headed to state Supreme Court.
The October 30 Attack on the Greenway, and the Days That Followed
The Shore Parkway Greenway runs along the waterfront in southwestern Brooklyn, tucked between the Belt Parkway and Upper New York Bay. The path is wide, popular with cyclists and runners, and well-used through the fall months. At 8:15 p.m. on October 30, it was full dark.
According to NYPD sources reporting through the New York Post and statements ADA Rossman made in court, Suarez was on the path near Bay 17th Street when she was stabbed twice in the neck. No motive has been offered by prosecutors. None appears in any public record connected to this case.
Suarez died three days later, on November 2.
For the five days that followed her death, investigators worked the case. The suspect police identified, Sayed Mohassib, 27, of Bensonhurst, was not arrested until November 7. During that interval, he continued to show up at his job. Mohassib was employed as a paraprofessional – a teacher's aide – at PS 200 in Bath Beach, a New York City public elementary school. Colleagues reported that his behavior in the days after October 30 was erratic and incoherent. Those reports did not directly lead to his arrest. Surveillance footage led to his arrest.
How Investigators Identified the Suspect
Law-enforcement sources told the New York Post that investigators tracked Mohassib through surveillance video recorded near the greenway. Footage captured a man leaving the area around the time of the attack. Police used facial recognition technology, cross-referencing the image against government records from both NYPD and Department of Education databases, to arrive at a name.
The criminal complaint, as reported by the Post, outlines statements Mohassib allegedly made to police after his arrest on November 7. These are allegations in a charging document. They are not established facts, and nothing in them has been adjudicated.
According to the complaint as reported, Mohassib told police he had gone to the greenway that night carrying a knife because, in his words, "people were going to come and kill his family." He allegedly told police he sat on a bench on the path and "became covered in blood." He also allegedly told them he "did not stab anyone."
The complaint further alleges that after the attack, Mohassib ran home. According to the complaint as reported, he emerged in his underwear and threw items into the building's garbage chute. He told police, according to the complaint, that he "got rid of the bloody clothing, and got rid of the knife." Investigators found blood on his hands and throughout his apartment, the complaint alleges. The walls of his room, prosecutors stated in court, were splattered with blood. He had attempted to clean it.
An earlier account, also reported, described Mohassib telling police he woke up covered in blood with no memory of events. That account has not been confirmed as his current stated position.
As for the knife: police believe it went into trash bound for a Staten Island landfill, then a New Jersey dump. Detectives were scouring a sanitation barge for it. The murder weapon has not been reported recovered.
ADA Rossman told the court at arraignment that Mohassib "made admissions and there are video recordings."
In Court: Arraignment, Plea, and Indictment
Mohassib was arraigned in Brooklyn Criminal Court later that night, before Judge John McPadden.
The charges at that stage, as reported in November 9 coverage: second-degree murder, tampering with physical evidence, and fourth-degree criminal possession of a weapon. He was held without bail.
The scene in the courtroom was spare. His defense attorney, Edward Mandery, made two requests of the court. He said a psychiatric evaluation was not needed at this time. He also asked that his client be placed in protective custody, citing the intensity of media coverage the arrest had drawn. Mohassib spoke only once during the proceeding, and only to correct the pronunciation of his name.
He pleaded not guilty to all three charges.
Three days later, on November 10, a grand jury voted to indict. The top count is second-degree murder. The indictment itself has not been unsealed; the full list of charges Mohassib now faces before the state Supreme Court remains unknown. What the grand jury heard, what additional counts may have been presented, and whether the charge picture shifted from the complaint – none of that is public yet.
District Attorney Eric Gonzalez issued a statement the day of the indictment: "Katie Suarez was a young woman with her whole life ahead of her, brutally taken from her loved ones in a senseless act of violence. Today's indictment marks an important step toward securing justice and I commend the NYPD for its swift and thorough investigation."
Questions About Screening and What Records Were Available
The fact that Mohassib was employed as a teacher's aide in a New York City public school has drawn immediate scrutiny from elected officials and triggered a formal response from the Department of Education.
The DOE suspended Mohassib after his arrest and stated it is moving to terminate his employment. In a statement, the department said: "The safety of our students is our very top priority. We are supporting the NYPD in their investigation however is needed."
Three elected officials representing the area – Councilmember Kayla Santosuosso, state Senator Andrew Gounardes, and Assemblymember-elect Chris McCreight – issued a joint statement saying the case "raises serious questions about how he came to be employed in a local public school." Those questions resolve to a pointed one: what background-check process applied to Mohassib's paraprofessional hire, and what records were available to the DOE at the time?
No specific screening failure has been documented in the public record.
The answer to that question is complicated, at least partly, by a background that sources described to the New York Post. According to those sources, Mohassib had a roughly six-week affiliation with the NYPD in 2022. He left the department with the intention of joining the Marines. Sources told the Post that the Marines deemed him mentally unfit and turned him away over mental-health concerns. He later attempted to rejoin the NYPD, those sources said, and was rejected again.
That account comes from Post sources only. It has not been confirmed through official documentation, court filings, or on-the-record statements from any agency. It does not appear in the unsealed complaint. It should be read as source-reported – not as an established record.
If accurate, though, it raises a question that neither the DOE nor any other agency has addressed publicly: whether records of Mohassib's earlier NYPD affiliation, or the reasons for his subsequent rejections, existed within systems the DOE could have accessed when processing his hire. Paraprofessionals in New York City schools are subject to background checks, but the specific scope of those checks – and whether they would capture the kind of history sources described to the Post – is not spelled out in what officials have said so far.
Mayor Zohran Mamdani addressed the case on November 9. "This attack on Katie Suarez was horrific," he said, expressing that his heart was with her loved ones "who have been shattered by this." He pledged to "hold the individual responsible fully accountable." He did not specifically address the screening questions.
Where the Case Stands
As of November 15, Sayed Mohassib is held without bail in Brooklyn. He faces a second-degree murder charge as the top count of an indictment the full contents of which remain sealed. He has pleaded not guilty to the three charges from his arraignment complaint.
The murder weapon has not been reported recovered.
The investigation appears closed in its basic outlines – an arrest, a grand jury indictment – but the legal process is at its earliest stage. The case now moves from Brooklyn Criminal Court to state Supreme Court, where Mohassib will be arraigned on the indictment. That proceeding had not been scheduled as of publication; it is expected within the coming weeks.
The organ donation that followed Suarez's death has been a persistent part of how this story has been covered, and for understandable reasons. Five organs, four recipients, ages 12 to 75, two states. Leonard Achan of LiveOnNY confirmed it. It is part of the public record of who Suarez was and what her registration as a donor made possible. The criminal case will proceed on its own track, in its own time.
What Happens Next
The next event on the court calendar is Mohassib's arraignment in state Supreme Court on the November 10 indictment. No date has been publicly set. When it happens, the indictment should be unsealed at that stage, giving the public – and the defense – a full picture of what charges he now faces.
RFTUV will follow several threads as this case develops: the full charge picture once the indictment is unsealed; whether a psychiatric evaluation is ordered and what its findings might mean for the proceedings; any further reporting on the status of the murder weapon; and the institutional question of whether the DOE's hiring and background-check processes for paraprofessionals will face a formal review in the wake of this case.
Murder indictments in New York move slowly. Motion practice, potential suppression hearings on the alleged admissions and video recordings, and pre-trial proceedings can extend a case by many months before a trial date is ever set. True Crime in the Valley will track this one.
Sayed Mohassib is charged, not convicted. He has pleaded not guilty, and he is presumed innocent unless and until a court finds otherwise.
Sources
- RFTUV Blotter, Nov 7
- RFTUV Blotter, Nov 8
- RFTUV Blotter, Nov 9
- RFTUV Blotter, Nov 10
- NY Post, Nov 7 (arrest and background)
- NY Post, Nov 7–8 (complaint and arraignment)
- NY Post, Nov 8 (case details)
- NY Post, Nov 8 (organ donation)
- FOX 5 New York (plea, DOE)
- Marathon Handbook (plea; CBS-sourced)
- People (LiveOnNY, Achan statement)
- CNN, Nov 8–10 (indictment, DA/DOE/mayoral statements)

